Blog

Over-the-Counter Tax Liens and Deeds: The Leftovers Market, Explained

What over-the-counter means

Not everything offered at a tax sale sells. When a certificate draws no bids, or a deed lot goes unsold, the county does not simply keep it in a drawer — many states let the county offer the leftovers directly to the public afterward, at a fixed price, with no auction. That is the over-the-counter (OTC) market, called 'lands available' or 'struck-off' inventory in some states.

OTC buying skips the two hardest parts of auction buying: competition and speed. There is no bid-down, no sale-day deposit scramble, and usually no 24-hour payment clock. In exchange, you accept the inventory the auction crowd already passed on.

Florida certificates: struck to the county at 18%

Florida runs the cleanest OTC example in the country. Certificates that receive no bids at the annual sale are struck off to the county at the maximum 18% interest rate. Afterward, the county tax collector can sell those certificates to investors over the counter — you pay the face amount plus accrued amounts, and you hold the certificate at the full 18%, the rate auction bidders competed down from.

That sounds like a loophole, and for researched parcels it can be a genuinely good trade: no competition, top statutory rate. But understand what the crowd told you on sale day. Thousands of bidders looked at that certificate and passed. Sometimes they passed because the parcel is obscure; sometimes because it is a landlocked strip, a drainage easement, or a lot with problems visible in thirty seconds of research. OTC rewards the investors who do the thirty seconds.

Deed leftovers: re-offers and lands-available lists

On the deed side, unsold properties follow a similar path. California counties may re-offer unsold parcels within 90 days, sometimes at reduced minimum prices authorized by the board of supervisors. In Florida, when a tax deed lot draws no bid, the property is struck off to the certificate holder — and if the certificate holder declines to take title, the property lands on the county's Lands Available list, where the public can buy it over the counter.

Michigan routes unsold foreclosed parcels through additional auctions at lower minimums and eventually to land banks or local governments. The details differ by state, but the pattern is universal: each round of non-sale lowers the price and lengthens the list of reasons to be careful.

How OTC pricing works

There is no bidding, so pricing is formulaic. OTC certificates typically cost the certificate's face value plus interest accrued to the purchase date and any fees. OTC deeds and lands-available parcels are priced at the amount required to clear the taxes and costs — often the same figure that failed to attract a bid — sometimes reduced after repeated failures to sell, depending on the county's authority.

Because the price is fixed, your edge is selection, not bidding skill. Two investors looking at the same OTC list will pay identical prices; the one who researched wins. LienToDeed alerts members when new properties are listed on OTC and lands-available inventories for the same reason it tracks auctions: the good leftovers get taken quickly once a list is published, and 'first come, first served' is its own kind of race.

The catch, stated plainly

Adverse selection is the whole story of the OTC market. Properties reach it by failing to attract a single bid from a crowd that included professionals. Common reasons include:

• No legal access — landlocked parcels with no road frontage
• Slivers and remnants: unusable strips left over from subdivisions or road projects
• Environmental or code problems visible in public records
• Values below the taxes owed — the opening amount already exceeds what the parcel is worth
• Title complications that make the deed path expensive relative to the parcel's value

A workable OTC strategy

Treat the OTC list as a research list, not a shopping list. Filter by county and parcel type, pull the property appraiser record for each candidate, check access and zoning, verify the amount owed against the parcel's realistic value, and only then buy. In Florida certificate terms, an 18% certificate on a buildable lot the crowd overlooked is a strong position; an 18% certificate on a worthless strip is an expensive lesson with a great interest rate.

Also verify before paying that the certificate or parcel is still available and still in the same status — OTC inventories change as owners redeem and buyers purchase, and county lists are not always updated the same day.

Questions

What does over-the-counter mean in tax sales?
It means buying directly from the county at a fixed price, outside the auction. Inventory is whatever did not sell at the sale — unsold lien certificates, unsold deed lots, and lands-available parcels. First come, first served, at the county's set amount.

Are Florida OTC certificates really at 18%?
Certificates struck to the county at the annual sale carry the maximum 18% rate, and buying one over the counter means holding it at that rate. The rate is real — but so is the reason nobody bid: research the parcel before assuming the crowd was wrong.

Can I negotiate the price on an OTC property?
Generally no. OTC prices are set by formula — taxes, interest, and costs — and counties have limited authority to discount. Some states allow reduced minimums on re-offers after repeated failed sales, but that is the county's schedule, not a negotiation.

Why would a good property end up over the counter?
It happens: obscure parcels, bad list timing, data errors in the published list, or counties with thin bidder turnout. It is the exception, not the pattern — which is why fast alerts on newly published OTC lists matter. The good ones do not sit.